< Browse > Home / Class Notes / Blog article: How Much Do You Rely on Your Cell or Mobile Phone in an Emergency?

| Mobile | RSS

How Much Do You Rely on Your Cell or Mobile Phone in an Emergency?

December 30th, 2006 | 13 Comments | Posted in Class Notes

Fire burns Walnut Creek home
By Malaika Fraley
CONTRA COSTA TIMES

WALNUT CREEK – An electrical malfunction sparked a two-alarm fire that caused $150,000 in damage to a Walnut Creek home today, the Contra Costa Fire District said.

Firefighters called to a Walnut Creek home at 9:53 a.m. found the front room engulfed in flames. The fire spread to a bedroom before it was extinguished 20 minutes later. Other rooms had heavy smoke and heat damage, said Battalion Chief Dave George.

Firefighters crawled into the house to search for an elderly woman that a man on the street feared was inside. They later learn the woman was away, George said. No one was injured.

The street was closed for three hours as crews mopped up.

Source: Contra Costa Times

The elderly woman is my mother. Fortunately, she was staying with me for the holidays when the fire broke out in her home.

I’m taking the time now to write because I feel the need to express my fears, frustration, and anger over our emergency response system. I must first preface this story by commending the brave men and women of the Pleasant Hill Fire Department and the kindness of the Walnut Creek Police and their dispatch unit.

I received a call on Thursday, December 28, 2006, my mother’s 77th birthday, from the Walnut Creek Police Department. Since I’m a training consultant for the City of Walnut Creek I initially did not think much of the call, but that quickly changed as I learned that my mother’s home was on fire and the fire department was attempting to find her. I let the officer know that my mother was not in the home and was safe with me.

I thought that the story was as simple as a house fire. Little did I know.

C.H.P. To Hire More 911 Dispatchers
After Complaints Of Backlog

Dec. 28 – KGO – This story is about something you hope never happens – a man called 911 on a cell phone today to report a fire, and was put on hold. The CHP says most 911 cell phone calls are routed to one call center, which can mean delays.

Max Burchett: “I tried to get 911 on the cell phone, but it never did go through.”

Max Burchett noticed flames shooting out of the living room window of his neighbor’s Walnut Creek home on his way to work. Worried the elderly disabled woman who lived there was inside, he pounded on the door, and then used his cell phone to call 911.

Max Burchett: “It said, if this is an emergency press any key – and it rang and rang and rang. A computer recording answered saying all our operators are busy.”

Frustrated, he called out to neighbors who got through to 911 on a land line. Fire crews converged on the quiet neighborhood in Walnut Creek and were able to extinguish the fire, luckily, no one was inside.

Alan Hartford, Contra Costa Fire Battalion Chief: “Unfortunately, the way the cell phone 911 system works, all the calls get routed to the CHP dispatch center. They’re working on a better fixes for 911 cellular usage — but as of right now it is what it is, and it’s unfortunate.”

The dispatch center in Vallejo handles 5,000 911 calls everyday. The positioning of cell towers in the Bay Area means all calls, except for parts of San Francisco and Marin County, are routed here. At any given moment, four to 11 operators are on call and it’s not uncommon to have to wait several minutes to be connected – but that’s about to change.

Elizabeth Gomes, CHP Dispatch Manager: “Currently, we’re in the process of hiring 40 to 50 new dispatchers within the next six to seven months and that will allow us to evenly distibute more people across our shifts and handle more 911 calls.”

So by summer 2007, cell phone users calling 911 should begin to notice a much faster response time.

Source: abc7news.com

Suppose my mother had been in that house? How many minutes were lost while Mr. Burchett risked his own life trying to gain access to the house while on hold with 911?

What scares me even more is that we have come to rely on our cell phones so heavily. I even armed my disabled mother with a cell phone and programmed a quick dial for 911 so she could carry it in her pocket at all times if an emergency was ever to occur. Suppose she had been trapped in that home when the fire broke out and called 911 on her cell and was put on hold? I sit here crying thinking about the possible outcome. While we may have lost possessions and pieces of family history we still have my mother. How many people may not have been as lucky as my mother and our family?

I know a lot of people who have given up their “land lines” in favor of cell phones; some for convenience some out of economical necessity. I have a lot of friends who have given their children cell phones because they think they will be “safer”. Many people have cell phones only for travel emergencies. We pay a state 911 tax on our cell phones to fund emergency services. So many count on these devices, but I wonder how many people will die while waiting on hold for a 911 operator…how many children will be abducted while trying to reach out for help with their cell phones?

If you do rely on your cell phone, program your local police department and local fire department’s numbers into your phone. Program friends who you know are home a lot and can call 911 from a “land line”. Don’t count on 911 from your cell phone.

We worry about web site accessibility on mobile devices when what we really need to worry about is access to emergency services on our mobile phones. Awareness needs to be brought to this issue because in my humble opinion summer of 2007 is not soon enough for change. I don’t live in a small town, I live in the San Francisco Bay Area; if this happens here, it can happen in your area — it can happen to you or your loved one.

The California Highway Patrol needs to hire and train more people now; “it is what it is” is not an acceptable answer when we’re talking about people’s lives.

Share and Enjoy:
  • Digg
  • Sphinn
  • del.icio.us
  • Facebook
  • Mixx
  • Google Bookmarks
  • StumbleUpon
  • Design Float
  • Reddit
  • Twitter
Leave a Reply 544 views, 1 so far today |
Tags:
Follow Discussion

13 Responses to “How Much Do You Rely on Your Cell or Mobile Phone in an Emergency?”

  1. Antonio Montesinos Says:

    Robin,
    Im sorry to hear about your moms home, i read about it in the paper. Thank God , she was with you. When you really need 911 they seem to always be busy. They seem to have a lot of goverment money to build Prisions but for community services they seem to lag for months.
    SUE them! Thats seems to make them work quicker.
    P.S. – Happy New year

  2. Ron Says:

    Also sorry to here about the fire and glad to hear your mom was with you at the time. I wasn’t aware of the problem of using 911 on cell phones, although my wife was. We’ll let our family know about this issue and let them make back up plans. This issue should certainly by addressed quickly.

    Happy New Year,

  3. Mike Dunn Says:

    Robin, sorry to hear about the fire at your mom’s home, glad to know that she is safe. One additional comment about cell phones I’d like to make, the CHP often talks about having ICE (in case of emergency) info programmed in users cell phones. I’ve programmed my cell and land lines with ICE designations for certain family and friends. That way if I’m unable to communicate, my phones will do the talking for me. I also carry a USB thumb drive that contains my music, resumes, websites, it also contains my ID, ICE contacts plus my Dr’s contact number. As a result of the 911 farce I will program a few local emergency numbers in to my phones. Take care Robin glad to know your mom is OK.

  4. Karen Says:

    Robin,
    I’m so very sorry to hear about the fire at your Mom’s home. Thank goodness that she was with you.
    Please tell me if I can help in any way.
    Ron had a great idea, and I’m going to program my phones with ICE info, plus add important info to my USB thumb drive.
    I wonder how we can get them to give a high priority to hiring the new dispatchers asap?
    Take care and again, I’m so glad that your Mom is ok.
    Karen

  5. Jerru Says:

    The present system in California was set up when most “mobile phones” were in cars. Since a 911 call was probably reporting an accident, the call was routed to the California Highway Patrol Dispatch Center. Unfortunately, the technology has not kept up with current cell phone usage, and in most cases, the calls are still routed to the CHP. Some cities have improved their systems, so that cell phone calls now go to their local dispatch center. Even if you are sure that your city has adopted the new technology, you should use your land-line when calling 911 when possible. The dispatcher knows exactly where the call is coming from. Someone calling to report an emergency may be excited or confused. If the dispatcher can determine the nature of the emergency, they can get help on the way, even if you don’t give them an address.

  6. Melissa Hagen Says:

    Hello
    Let me know what else I can do Robin. Write to the Gov? Write to State Assembly people?

  7. marjie Says:

    So glad your Mother was with you. Your such a good daughter!!
    I am now very worried about those darn cell phones. Just one more reason for me to not get one.
    Take care
    marjie

  8. Ken Says:

    I’m actually applying for the CHP dispatcher position. I believe I have the qualifications they seek, I’m just crossing my fingers and hope that they pick me. I would love to help!

  9. SherBear Says:

    Hey Rob-
    Read the email link to your story on the blog. Geez. Thank goodness for guardian angels and you! Glad Mom’s aok. It IS a problem that needs more public awareness. The more heat the public puts on the government-ie. media attention is always good as well as letters-the more chance we have of something actually getting done. Hope you are well.
    May the New Year bring happiness and prosperity to all of us!
    One of Your Fav Pest-(Prior)-Students-
    SherBear

  10. Thomas Says:

    Robin,
    I’m sorry to hear about your mother’s house fire.Thank God that she was with you at the time.I know how hard things are for you at this time.Just wanted to say that my heart goes out to you and your family.Just remember things will get better with time.
    P.S. Give your mother a hug for me.And one for you too.

  11. dos palos resident Says:

    hello, we witnessed both fires and want to wish you the best as your mother and you recover.

  12. ming Says:

    I am so glad that your mother was safe at home with you. I feel your anguish and frustration. The same thing happened to my sister. Her car skidded and crashed in the freeway. She called 911 and she was place on hold for several minutes and they started asking the routine questions, press #1 for spanish…yada..yada..yada…
    She was in a state of shock and could not believe that they let her go though that when her car was going to explode anytime….
    Luckily some truck drivers stop to help her out of the car and call CHP and help her out of the accident.
    That was 6 years ago, and she said that 911 changed since than…from what you shared with us, did not seem to change much…

Trackbacks

  1. Please Vote Online to Help the Contra Costa Fire District » Robin’s Blog  
BubbleRelaxPlasmaBubbleDripPlaying with Water and LightPlaying with Water and LightPlaying with Water and LightPlaying with Water and LightPlaying with Water and LightwetJust Posing